Where are you?
EnergyBrainYour solar report
← All case studies
CASE STUDY · NSW

The Saltwood House: which solar and battery system pays best for a big family home?

One roof, three systems priced by Emily. We compare them on payback, net present value and the real cost of owning them for 15 years.

3 systems compared7 min readUpdated 15 Oct 2026
Aerial view of the Saltwood House: three timber and sandstone pavilions with black solar panels on north-facing roofs, beside a green-tiled lap pool
Illustrative render. The Saltwood House is fictional.
1.9–2.4 yrs
Fastest payback: Smart Starter
$16.8k
Highest 15-year NPV after ownership costs: Smart Starter
50 kWh
Largest battery, for blackout backup and EV charging
Short answer. For the Saltwood House as it is today, the 6.6 kW Smart Starter system with a 9.6 kWh battery is the best financial investment: it pays back in about two years and has the highest net present value (NPV) at 10, 15 and 20 years. The 19.8 kW Rebate Maximiser with a 50 kWh battery saves the most each year and suits a family planning more EVs, all-electric appliances and blackout backup.

What is the Saltwood House?

The Saltwood House is a fictional family home on a bushy, sloping block on Sydney’s Northern Beaches. We use it to show how Emily compares systems for one roof. The pricing and savings come from an Emily estimate for a comparable large home; the house, family and photos are illustrative.

It is built as three sandstone and timber pavilions, each under a single sloping roof tilted to the north. Those three roofs, plus a detached garage, give Emily room for up to 45 panels.

Street approach to the Saltwood House with sandstone walls, timber cladding and a timber garage
Street approach
Green-tiled lap pool beside a timber deck and sunken outdoor lounge
Lap pool and deck
Living room with a timber-battened ceiling, terrazzo floor and olive velvet sofa
Living room
Kitchen with a travertine island, sage cabinetry and a long timber dining table
Kitchen and dining
FeatureThe Saltwood House
Bedrooms5 plus a study
Bathrooms3
Pool25 m lap pool
Usable roof faces4 (three pavilions and the garage)
LocationNorthern Beaches, Sydney NSW

Where does a house like this use power?

A big home uses a lot of power after sunset, when grid power costs the most. A battery pays its way by moving midday solar into the evening.

Pool pump

Runs daily. Schedule it for midday and it runs on sunshine.

Air-con

Five bedrooms and a study cooled through a Sydney summer, mostly in the evening.

EV charging

Overnight top-ups in the garage come straight from the battery.

Family of five

Laundry, kitchen and three bathrooms running morning and night.

What three systems did Emily price?

Emily mapped the roof in 3D and returned three options. Every price includes the government rebate.

BIGGEST YEARLY SAVING

Rebate Maximiser

19.8 kWSYSTEM
45PANELS
50 kWhBATTERY
Net investment
$24,300–$31,894
Rebate included
$11,966
Payback
5.4–7.1 yrs
Saving per year
$3,886–$4,295
10-year NPV
$2.9k
15-year NPV$13.1k

High Performer

13.2 kWSYSTEM
30PANELS
50 kWhBATTERY
Net investment
$22,061–$28,955
Rebate included
$10,229
Payback
5.7–7.4 yrs
Saving per year
$3,312–$3,661
10-year NPV
$0.9k
15-year NPV$9.6k
HIGHEST NPV

Smart Starter

6.6 kWSYSTEM
15PANELS
9.6 kWhBATTERY
Net investment
$5,196–$6,819
Rebate included
$4,246
Payback
1.9–2.4 yrs
Saving per year
$2,506–$2,769
10-year NPV
$13.9k
15-year NPV$20.6k

Why compare on NPV instead of payback or IRR?

Payback only tells you how fast the money comes back, and a high return (IRR) on a small system can hide how little it earns in dollars. Net present value (NPV) is what the system is worth to you today once future savings are discounted back, so a dollar saved in year 12 counts for less than a dollar saved next year.

Rebate MaximiserHigh PerformerSmart Starter
-$30k-$20k-$10k$0k$10k$20k$30kYear 0Year 5Year 10Year 15Year 20$26k Smart$21k Rebate$16k High

Model: midpoint of each price and saving range, net investment paid in year 0, savings falling 0.5% a year as panels age, discounted at 5% a year. At a 7% discount rate the order is the same.

Which system is the best investment?

On the numbers, the smallest system wins. Smart Starter has the highest NPV at 10, 15 and 20 years. Rebate Maximiser saves about $1,450 more each year, but costs about $22,000 more up front. Over 15 years that extra spend only earns back roughly what it costs.

High Performer costs about $2,600 less than Rebate Maximiser but saves about $600 less each year. On this roof, most families would choose one of the other two.

So why would anyone choose the 50 kWh Rebate Maximiser?

The NPV prices this house as it is today. Families who choose the bigger system are paying for what the house will need next, and for peace of mind.

The lights stay on

A 9.6 kWh battery covers the fridge, lights and wifi for an evening. 50 kWh runs the whole house, air-con and pool pump included, through a day-long outage.

The house will use more power

A second EV, a heat-pump hot water system and switching off gas can roughly double usage. Smart Starter’s savings stop growing; Rebate Maximiser has room.

Adding more later costs more

Expanding later means a second installation and call-out fee, and the federal battery rebate is set to step down over time.

Earnings the estimate leaves out

A big battery can join a virtual power plant (VPP) and get paid at peak times. Home EV charging also replaces petrol. Neither is in the saving above.

Protection against price rises

If electricity prices climb, the saving rises with them. The bigger system protects more of the bill.

Timber-lined garage wall with four graphite home battery cabinets, a hybrid inverter, a switchboard and an EV charger
A 50 kWh battery bank, inverter and EV charger in the garage
SMART STARTERBest return on the house as it is today
REBATE MAXIMISERBest buy for where the house is going

What does it really cost to own over 15 years?

A quote shows the install price. Over 15 years three more costs come in: batteries slowly hold less charge, the system needs the odd check-up, and the inverter usually needs replacing once.

Today’s dollars, discounted at 5% a year. Battery wear: savings fall 1.5% a year instead of 0.5%. Check-ups: $250 every three years. Inverter: one replacement in year 12, $4,000 for the larger systems and $2,500 for Smart Starter. All are assumptions.
SystemHeadline 15-yr NPVBattery wearCheck-upsNew inverterReal 15-yr NPV
Rebate Maximiser$13,092−$2,389−$823−$2,227$7,653
High Performer$9,599−$2,036−$823−$2,227$4,513
Smart Starter$20,551−$1,540−$823−$1,392$16,795

What costs might not be in a solar quote?

Not every home needs these, so they are left out of the numbers above. Ask your installer to confirm each one in writing before you sign.

Switchboard upgrade

$1,000–$3,000

Older switchboards often can’t safely take a solar and battery system.

Two-storey or steep roof

Varies

Scaffolding and roof safety gear add to the install. Tile roofs can cost more than metal.

Re-roofing later

Varies

Panels have to come off and go back on if the roof is repaired or replaced.

Inverter warranty extension

$150–$600

Optional; some brands only allow it if you register within 12 months.

Mismatched equipment

Warranty risk

Some batteries must pair with a specific inverter brand, or both warranties can be void.

Export limits

Lower earnings

Your network may cap how much you can send to the grid, and feed-in rates keep falling.

Emily, EnergyBrain roof assessment

See your three options, priced for your roof

Emily measures your actual roof and shows each system’s price, saving and payback as ranges. About a minute, no sign-up.

Get your solar report

Frequently asked questions

Which solar system pays back fastest for a large home?

For the Saltwood House, the 6.6 kW Smart Starter with a 9.6 kWh battery pays back in 1.9 to 2.4 years, because it costs about $6,000 after a $4,246 rebate and saves about $2,600 a year.

Is a bigger solar and battery system always a better investment?

No. In this case study the 19.8 kW, 50 kWh system saves about $1,450 more a year than the smallest option but costs about $22,000 more, so its 15-year NPV is lower. A bigger system makes sense when your power use will grow, or when backup and energy security matter to you.

What is NPV and why does it matter for solar?

Net present value is what a system’s future savings are worth today, minus what you pay. It lets you compare systems of different sizes in dollars, which payback period and IRR alone cannot.

How long do solar panels, inverters and batteries last?

Panels usually last 25 to 30 years or more, with performance warranties of 25 to 30 years. String and hybrid inverters typically last 10 to 15 years and cost about $1,500 to $4,500 to replace. Batteries usually carry a 10-year warranty that guarantees 60% to 70% of the original capacity.

Do solar panels need yearly maintenance?

There is no compulsory yearly fee. Rain does most of the cleaning. Installers usually suggest a safety and performance check every few years, roughly $150 to $300 a visit.

Keep reading

Sources

Editorial note (October 2026): the Saltwood House, its family and its photos are fictional and the images are AI-generated renders. Prices, rebates and savings are modelled estimates, not quotes, and actual results vary by property. Ownership costs and NPV are calculated from stated assumptions. Prices, rebates and incentives must be checked again for the date and location of any installation. This is general information, not personalised financial advice.